We now begin to read about the life of Joseph. In this parashah, the effects of parents’ mistakes become evident in their children’s lives. Some rabbis try to clean up their act, while others are very critical, even negative. We always need to find the balance. These narratives help us to apply sound principles in our lives, and later, in the Torah given to Moses, various regulations are provided to repair relationships and clarify what our forefathers did. For example, Abraham married his sister, and later, the Torah warns us not to do that. It sets up the ruling that, if the first wife is hated, the position of the bechor still belongs to her son and not the son of a later wife who is loved.

The principles of the Torah teach us to grow. Although it is good to learn from our own mistakes, it is far better and less painful to learn from the mistakes of others. Today, the legal system sets precedents under which a judge renders a verdict based on specific aspects of a crime.  A case that follows would then be judged by precedent rather than on its own merits, leading to the accumulation of rules and regulations based on precedents. This goes against the Torah, which also teaches us how to avoid these problems.

Parashat Vayeshev begins with, “This is the generation of Jacob” and then speaks of Joseph, but says nothing about his other sons. What’s wrong with this picture? It states that he loves Joseph because he is the son of his old age, but all his children, including Reuben, his eldest, were children of his old age. He was not a teenager. The Torah is teaching us that there was prejudice here. Jacob showed such an obvious preference for Joseph that he gave him a very special coat, differentiating him from the others. This caused them to hate Joseph. The Torah would later repair these types of errors. Vayikra (Lev.) 19:17 warns us: “Do not hate your brother in your heart; rather, you must reason with him, rebuke your neighbor and do not allow yourself to sin because of him.”

This favoritism created dysfunction within Jacob’s family, but there wasn’t one moment when the brothers went and asked Joseph to dialogue. They might have tried to reason with Joseph, saying, “You are misbehaving; correct your actions because you’re provoking us to dislike you.” And why didn’t they go first to their father and tell him, “Father, what you are doing is unfair because you’re forcing us to dislike our brother, who you’re spoiling”?  Joseph was being treated like a king, home in the tent with his father, while the others were out working with the flocks. Joseph would be the inheritor,  treated like the bechor, the firstborn, instead of Reuben, Leah’s first son, the number one above all the brothers, because Joseph was the first son of his beloved Rachel.  By failing to prepare Leah’s sons for leadership, Jacob created division in his family. They might not have been as smart as Joseph, but he could have worked on preparing them. All of Jacob’s actions led to what happened to Joseph. Some of our sages say this was really providence, or that it was the fulfillment of the prophecy in Genesis 15, where we read about the covenant of the parts, in which Abraham was told that Israel would be a slave in Egypt for a period of time.  Was Jacob told that this prophecy would be fulfilled by making all his other children hate Joseph? Favoritism is the worst thing that parents can do in a family. We learn later that the Torah will repair this type of anomaly by granting the right of bechor to the firstborn of the first wife, even if she was not the loved one (Deut. 21:15-17).

Now Joseph was the dreamer of dreams and the interpreter of dreams, but look at the first dream that he tells his brothers. Was it about someone else or about himself? He acts like he is the center of the universe. It’s as if he’s telling his brother and his father, “I am here, I exist, and I am everything”. His father, who was crazy about him, “kept it in his heart,” but the brothers grew so upset with him that they couldn’t even speak peaceably to him; they began to hate him more and more. But why didn’t they ever approach him to try to alleviate the situation? Whenever communication is cut, hatred grows. This happens when people speak behind someone’s back. This creates a terrible attitude and builds hatred toward others, even if they don’t deserve it, but that’s what remains in the minds of the people. I just read to you from Vayikra 19:17, which says not to hold anything against your brother in your heart, because if you do, it will only increase. When you hold something against someone, two things happen: it destroys both the person you hate and it destroys you.

That is why understanding and forgiveness are so important.  You need to address and discuss the issue.  People can say, “Oh, I forgive you, but I don’t want to see you again for the rest of my life.”  The truth is that you have not dealt with the issue. You always need to be open to talk to people, but in the right way, not according to what other people say, or according to how they make demands on you, but in a calm, open way, treating everybody equally.  If you know that someone is upset with you, clarify by asking what they think you did wrong.  If you don’t accept that you’ve done anything wrong, but the other person thinks you have, and you keep saying no, that shuts the door to dialogue. You can tell them, “I wasn’t aware, I didn’t realize that and then say I’m sorry”. But you’re acknowledging that for that person, you did something wrong.

Dialogue and clarification usually make things right. It was already too late for Joseph; too much hatred had grown in the hearts of his brothers. The accumulation of hatred ends in destruction if you don’t deal with it. You know, to kill other people, you need to hate them, wanting them to disappear. That’s why wars start. That’s what is happening right now with the Arabs in the so-called occupied territories. They believe that the land belongs to them. They teach their children from a very early age to hate Jews, to hate Israel. They call Israel the monkeys and dogs, and they use words in Islam that are the worst thing that anyone could say – that Jewish people don’t have a soul, that we don’t deserve to live.  Children of three or four years of age are being taught that. How do you think they’re going to grow up,  loving Israel, wanting to have a peaceful relationship with Israel? What does the United Nations do? Appeasement will never end the problem.

Jacob behaved as if he were oblivious to this problem. He sent Joseph to find the boys and to bring back a report about them. Their hatred had festered to the point that they sold him as a slave; they might just as easily have killed him. Our sages say that this had to happen, that it was pre-ordained from the time of Abraham’s vision and that God would use this for something better. I am not so sure that is true. If things in families are not settled, they will be spread to future generations.  People ask what caused the empire of the South to separate from the North? The root of bitterness that began with Joseph and Judah continued among the children of King David, who never dealt with their hatred toward one another! And this is happening again in our day between Israel and the Arab countries. Unless there is proper communication, there can never be a solution.

Are there any people in your household, your family, your friends, relatives, workplace or community who you do not want to have anything to do with?  Have you had a good dialogue with them?  If you genuinely have tried to speak with them and they don’t want to talk to you, take your peace, and let it go. You’ve done your part, but always leave the door open to future dialogue.  By the way, texting is the worst form of communication, and emails do not work; they are too easy to misinterpret. You can’t see their face or hear the emotion in their voices.  Have you made up your mind and closed yourself off to dialogue? However, once you choose to engage in conversation, you need to be open to receiving criticism, and positive criticism is constructive for our growth. Can you imagine how Joseph and his brothers spoke to each other? It says they couldn’t speak peaceably to him.

The Torah teaches a basic principle –  not everything is hunky dory; we need to work hard to have peace, to not hold onto hatred in our hearts because that leads to sin. The Torah is amazingly wise and teaches us how to live a better life. It teaches us that we each have a different personality: some are always flying high and positive, while others are ho-hum or always negative. Neither extreme is good; instead, we need to learn to be in between, to be more balanced. If Jacob’s children had dared to confront their father, the outcome might have been quite different.

We see that Jacob didn’t learn from his father, Isaac, who favored Esau. This is the perfect example of midah keneged midah – measure for measure, when he held in his hands Joseph’s coat smeared in the blood of a slain lamb.  Jacob’s sons deceived him in the same way he deceived his father, Isaac, when he wore the skin of a goat, pretending he was Esau. In the last parashah, Jacob fought with the man and made up with Esau, but their battle continues to this day, depicting that because you were forgiven once, the rest of your life will be perfect or that you won’t make any more mistakes. Religions teach that all we need to say is, “I’m sorry, forgive me,” or we repeat certain confessions, and the rest of our lives will be hunky dory, and we don’t need to worry about our sins.  The Torah teaches us that we are capable of sinning for the rest of our lives. That’s why we constantly need to renew our relationship with the Creator through true teshuva.

Like Joseph, we all need to go through our own personal transformation. His time as a slave and in prison helped Joseph to deal with himself and later to be more empathetic toward his brothers. He began at the top among his brothers and ended up at the bottom – in prison. In the next Parashah Miketz, he will start at the bottom – in prison and end up at the top, viceroy of Egypt.

This picture teaches us that although we go through ups and downs in our lives, through difficult times, our Creator will always remain faithful to us, despite ourselves, and even if we are not always faithful to Him.

I don’t want to end without quickly mentioning Judah. Despite what he and his brothers did, they had the principles passed down from their fathers, Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, who taught them to revere and respect the Creator.  Although there were times when they set those principles aside, they always came back and did the right thing. Judah, however, went against Isaac and married a Canaanite. Almost all of Jacob’s children married foreigners despite what our sages say.  This shows us the importance of the mother in the home. If the children do not have a mother with good principles, they have a greater chance of going astray.  From Judah and Tamar, his daughter-in-law, would come twins from whom would come the line of King David.  There is no time to develop this today, but the Torah shows us that not everything can be explained. It is my prayer that we start dialoguing and seeking understanding; that we do not talk badly about others, and clear up old issues that separate us.

Shabbat Shalom